On the front page no less

Most of the usage problems studied by Mittins et al. in the late 1960s (Attitudes to English Usage, 1970) have since increased in acceptability. This is what we tested by repeating their survey in the form of usage polls on this blog, and it is what Carmen Ebner and I, for some features at least, reported on in our article ‘Prescriptive attitudes to English usage‘, published last year. To our surprise, though, we found that dangling adjuncts (as in Pulling the trigger, the gun went off) had increased least of all. Why hadn’t it? Good question, but today I want to raise a different question.

My question today has to do with the announcement of an interview with the Dutch writer Esther Gerritsen on the front page of  yesterday’s NRC Weekend, a quality Dutch newspaper. “Als kind was Jezus mijn grote voorbeeld,” it reads. In English: “As a child Jesus was my great example.” Surely this was not right? But the interview actually did cite Esther Gerritsen’s words like this. It must be professional deformation that made me trip over this even in Dutch, but more interestingly, why is there such a difference in attitude to the dangling adjunct between the Dutch and the English? Finding out that he had used a dangling participle in a letter to the editor made Ian McEwan cringe with embarrassment (Mother Tongue), but clearly not Esther Gerritsen or the NRC editors. How come there are such different attitudes to the dangling adjunct between these two languages?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized, usage features and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to On the front page no less

  1. Tony Parr says:

    Hi Ingrid, might it be because ‘Als kind’ is regarded as a standard sentence-opener in Dutch?

  2. Possibly! As an editor, would you correct this?

    • Tony Parr says:

      Well, I only edit in English, so I asked my wife, who’s a Dutch native speaker. She recognises it as a dangler, but is not unduly concerned by it, partly because the meaning is so clear – and also due to the nature of ‘als kind’ as a set expression. Not a patch on the danglers she often comes across in death announcements, e.g. ‘Na een moedig gedragen lijden hebben wij afscheid genomen van…’

  3. Hmmm, not impressed. I asked my colleagues, editors at the University’s news department, who were equally unimpressed! One of them suggested this as a possible interpretation of the sentence: ‘Tenzij het kindeke Jezus natuurlijk je grote voorbeeld was. Toen ‘ie lekker in die kribbe lag en goud en mirre cadeau kreeg.’ Adorable!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s